Why You Hate Photos of Yourself but Not Your Mirror: What a 1977 Study Found

Why photos of yourself can feel wrong when the mirror feels fine, what a 1977 study of mirror images and true images found about the face you prefer, and why the face you flinch at is the one the people closest to you know best.
By Magda Kazoli, Certified Image Consultant | Creator of the Visual Voice® System
Someone shows you a photo, a group shot from lunch or a candid taken at a birthday, and everyone else in it looks lovely. Then your eye finds you, your stomach drops a little, and before you've even thought about it you're saying the familiar things, delete that one, I look awful, I'm just not photogenic.
You've probably said it a hundred times, and over years of flinching at pictures you've come to believe it completely, that the camera simply doesn't like you and never will.
I'd like to offer you a different explanation, because I don't think the problem is your face at all. What's happening is stranger than looking bad in pictures, and a good deal kinder, since you're looking at a version of your face you've never had the chance to get used to, and there's a study from 1977 that explains why.
This piece is about the face in the mirror and the face in the photo, why they aren't quite the same face, why most of us prefer one and flinch at the other, and what it means that the one you can't stand is the one the people closest to you see every day.
The Difference Between Your Mirror Face and Your Photo Face
There's something you've probably never had a reason to notice, which is that the face you see in the mirror isn't the face the rest of the world sees, because a mirror flips it.
Every morning of your life the mirror has shown you a reversed version of yourself, so your parting sits on the opposite side, the little freckle is on the other cheek, and the smile that rises slightly higher on one side rises on the other instead, which means it's still you, only back to front.
That flipped face is the one you know by heart. You've studied it while brushing your teeth, doing your make-up and checking yourself before you leave the house, tens of thousands of times over the years, until it became the face you think of as yours.
A camera does something different, because it records you the way you actually are, the way someone across the table sees you, with your parting on its real side and the freckle where it really sits. When you look at that photo, a quiet part of your brain registers that something isn't quite right without being able to say what, a little like a familiar word spelled slightly wrong, and the reason is simply that it's the reverse of the face you know.
What the 1977 Study of Mirror Images Found
This isn't only a nice theory, because three psychologists at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Theodore Mita, Marshall Dermer and Jeffrey Knight, tested it in 1977. They photographed women from the front and printed each photo two ways, once as the true image, the face as a camera and everyone else sees it, and once flipped, the mirror version each woman saw of herself every morning (Source: Mita, T. H., Dermer, M., & Knight, J., 1977, Reversed facial images and the mere-exposure hypothesis, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35(8), pages 597 to 601).
They ran two studies. In the first, 37 women students each brought along a close female friend, and in the second, 38 women each brought the man they were dating or living with, and every woman looked at the two prints of her own face and said which one she liked better, and so did her friend or partner.
The women leaned towards the mirror version, the flipped one they saw every day, and in the second study around seven in ten of them chose it. Their friends and partners leaned the other way, towards the true image, although their preference was weaker and only came through clearly when the partners in the second study were asked to choose several times over.
Take a moment with that, because it's the heart of the whole thing. You tend to prefer the mirror you, the people close to you tend to prefer the real you, and the real you is the one in every photograph.

Why Your Brain Prefers the Face It Knows: The Mere-Exposure Effect
The reason has a name, the mere-exposure effect, and it's one of the most solid findings in psychology. In 1968 the psychologist Robert Zajonc showed that simply seeing something again and again is enough to make us like it more, whether it's a shape, a word or a face, not because it's any better but because it has become familiar (Source: Zajonc, R. B., 1968, Attitudinal effects of mere exposure, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 9(2, Pt. 2), pages 1 to 27).
It's far from a small or shaky effect, either. When Robert Bornstein brought together 208 experiments from the twenty years after Zajonc's paper, he found that it held up reliably across them (Source: Bornstein, R. F., 1989, Exposure and affect: Overview and meta-analysis of research, 1968 to 1987, Psychological Bulletin, 106(2), pages 265 to 289).
Put the two together and the flinch makes sense. You've seen your mirror face tens of thousands of times, so your brain is fond of it, and you've seen your true face far less often, so it treats that face as a mild stranger, which means the flinch you feel at a photo isn't your honest verdict on how you look, it's your brain noticing something unfamiliar, and the unfamiliar always feels a little wrong at first.
Disliking your face in photos and simply not being used to it yet are two very different things, and it's worth knowing which one you're dealing with. It's close to the reason I wrote about in why the sharpest eye in the room can't see itself, because even a woman with a very good eye for everyone else can find her own reflection the hardest thing to read.
What the People Who Love You See When They Look at You
This is the part I most want you to hear, because it turns years of flinching on its head. The face you can't stand in photos is the face the people closest to you see all the time, across a thousand dinners and conversations, and when they picture you, they picture that face rather than the mirror one, which they've never actually seen.
The study can't tell us what any one person thinks of your face, and it didn't look at photographs taken on phones, so what follows is my own reading of it. To the people who love you, that face is simply yours, the one they know, and the only person likely to struggle with it is you, because you're the one who sees it least.
Phones have muddled this even further. Many front cameras show you a mirrored preview while you're taking the photo and then, depending on the phone and its settings, save the true version instead, so the selfie that looked fine on the screen can feel wrong once it's saved, even though nothing changed except which way round you were looking at yourself.
None of this makes the mirror your enemy, it simply only ever showed you one version and got you attached to it, so making peace with photographs is really a matter of spending a little more time with the real face, until it stops feeling like a stranger and starts to feel like someone you know.
How Discomfort With Your Own Image Reaches Your Wardrobe
There's a reason this matters beyond the photo album, because if you can't quite trust what you see when you look at yourself, it's hard to trust yourself when you're getting dressed either.
A woman who flinches at her own image tends to second-guess everything. She holds a dress up against herself and can't tell whether she's reacting to the dress or to the flinch, she avoids the mirror and the camera, and little by little she stops trusting her own eye about anything to do with how she looks, so the doubt that started with a photo quietly moves into the wardrobe, much like the self-consciousness I described in how an outfit that makes you self-conscious drains your focus.
Knowing that the discomfort is familiarity rather than fact gives you back a little steadiness in front of the mirror, and that steadiness is what everything else rests on, because it's very hard to dress a woman you can't bear to look at, and so much easier to dress one you've made your peace with.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do I look different in photos than in the mirror?
Because a mirror shows you a reversed version of your face, while a camera records it the right way round, the way other people see you. You've looked at the reversed version thousands of times, so the true one in a photo can feel slightly off, even though it's simply your face as everyone else knows it.
Is the mirror or the photo closer to how other people see me?
The photo is closer, because it shows your face the right way round, with your parting and features on their real sides. The mirror shows the same face flipped, which is why it's the version you know best and, for most of us, the version we prefer.
Why do I hate photos of myself?
Often it's the mere-exposure effect, the finding Robert Zajonc showed in 1968 that we like things more the more often we see them. You've seen your mirror face far more often than your true face, so the true face in a photo can feel unfamiliar, and the unfamiliar tends to feel a little wrong at first, which is a different thing from looking bad.
Do other people prefer my real face or my mirror image?
In the 1977 study by Theodore Mita, Marshall Dermer and Jeffrey Knight, the women leaned towards their mirror image while their close friends and partners leaned towards the true image, the face they were used to seeing. The partners' preference was weaker but came through clearly when they chose several times, so the face you flinch at is the one the people close to you know best.

Your Next Step: Closet Confidence
If you've spent years flinching at yourself, in photos and in the mirror, and letting that doubt decide what you wear, the way through is learning to trust your own eye again and to dress the woman you actually see.
Closet Confidence is my four-week self-study course, built on the first principles of the Visual Voice® System, for the woman who has stopped trusting what she sees when she looks at herself and feels it every time she gets dressed. It's where the face in the photo and the woman in the wardrobe start to feel like the same person again.
The course is open now, and you can start today.
You were never unphotogenic, you just hadn't been properly introduced to your own face, so take a little time to get to know her, and start dressing her like someone you're glad to see.
About the Author
Magda Kazoli has spent twenty years in communication and six as a certified Image Consultant, working with women across 18 countries on their wardrobe and on the presence they carry into every room.
She created the Visual Voice® System for the woman who senses that something has shifted. A new chapter. A career change. A quiet feeling that the woman in the mirror doesn't quite match the woman she's become. The wardrobe is full. Nothing feels right. That's the gap Magda works on.
Over 900 women across the UK, the US, and Europe have gone through her Closet Confidence programme. They come out with a clear visual identity, a wardrobe they can actually use, and the confidence to get dressed without second-guessing themselves.
Based in Athens, working internationally. Certified by House of Colour UK. Accredited member of FIPI, the Federation of Image Professionals International.
Stay Connected:
Instagram: Magda Kazoli - Notes on dressing the body of the woman you are now
Facebook: Magda Kazoli - A community of women rebuilding wardrobes that match their actual chapter
LinkedIn: Magda Kazoli - Visible authority for women in the second half
YouTube: Magda Kazoli - Longer conversations on style, identity, and the woman you are becoming
TikTok: @magdakazoli - Honest takes on body change, fabric, and the wardrobe that stopped fitting
